My son Zach has been hanging out and painting with me in the studio the last number of weeks and we have been discussing and researching how to get his work more solidly in the market as he works toward becoming creatively self-sustaining.
Check out his newly developing website at zachtouchonart.com and sign up to his mail list.
& please follow him on Instagram
This has been a big opportunity for me to compare entering today’s art market compared to the old school, pre-internet world I grew up in. So I have been researching what people are saying out there, mostly on instagram the last while and this has given me some fuel for thought.
So I have come up with a series of articles addressing what I have been hearing and what I think about it. I am looking at the art community, the collector community and the art market.
The Fixed Pie vs. The Expanding Feast
Part 1 of 4: Scarcity, Generosity, and the Art World Ecosystem
Imagine sitting down at a poker table with three other people. Each of you puts a hundred dollars into the center. For the next two hours, chips slide back and forth across the felt. At the end of the night, one person walks away with four hundred dollars, and three people walk away with nothing.
No new money was created at that table. Every dollar won had to be lost by someone else.
In game theory, this is a zero-sum game - a closed system where gains and losses cancel each other out. Now imagine a different table: two people sit down with cups of coffee and trade ideas until both stand up with a clearer vision and a spark for something neither could have conceived alone. Nobody lost a dime, yet both walked away richer. Economists call that positive-sum, though in daily life we recognize it under much more human names: scarcity versus abundance, or competitive versus generative thinking.
Two Ways of Seeing the World
Both realities exist. If you are bidding on a single house, competing for one open job, or vying for a limited spot on a gallery roster, the rules are genuinely competitive. Only one person gets the keys; only one artist gets that wall.
The trouble begins when we carry the logic of the poker table into parts of life that have no fixed boundaries.
Because humans evolved to survive in environments of material shortage, we easily slip into a scarcity mindset as a default strategy. We begin to see the world as a fixed pie, convinced that there is only so much recognition, success, or creative territory to go around. Under scarcity thinking, every peer looks like a rival:
Knowledge becomes a secret to hoard rather than a tool to share.
Another person’s breakthrough feels like a personal setback, breeding quiet envy instead of curiosity.
Relationships turn into ledgers, keeping strict score of who gave more and who owes whom.
The Generative Mindset
A generative mindset starts from the opposite premise: meaning, culture, and imagination are not finite resources.
Instead of fighting over a single slice of a shrinking pie, you realize you are sitting at an expanding feast - a table where every guest brings new ingredients, new recipes, and new nourishment to share. When a composer writes a remarkable piece of music or a painter discovers a new visual language, they do not use up the world’s supply of creativity; they expand what everyone else realizes is possible.
Where the Studio Meets the Market
Nowhere is the friction between these two viewpoints more revealing than in the relationship between the creative community and the collector community - a tension I have spent decades navigating inside my own studio practice, and one I am revisiting with fresh eyes today while helping my son build a self-sustaining, independent creative life.
At its heart, the creative community runs on generative abundance. An artist steps into the studio with raw materials , imagination, a set of skills and brings something into existence that never existed before. Artists thrive when ideas cross-pollinate, when studios stay in conversation, and when one person’s discovery opens doors for others. If put into economic terms, imagine the amount of intellectual property being generated by the creative community on a daily basis. It is staggering. If that community were willing and able to capitalize on that value, the rest of the world could not afford it.
The collector community, by contrast, is built around stewardship and acquisition - and here, scarcity enters the room. Unique artworks are finite. Wall space is finite. Budgets are finite. Time and attention are finite. When collectors buy serious work at middle-tier gallery prices, or when artists eye a limited number of exhibition walls, competitive zero-sum mechanics naturally surface.
Yet even here, the choice of mindset determines whether the culture flourishes or dries up:
Purely competitive collecting treats art like a status trophy or a speculative chip, pulling energy out of the studio and narrowing the circle of who gets to participate.
Generative patronage - supporting living artists, respecting gallery ecosystems while opening direct relationships online, and living with art over decades - turns finite acquisition into fuel for future creation.
Toward a Living Ecosystem
When artists and collectors see themselves as locked in a scarcity game, everyone loses: artists guard their territory in isolation, and collectors chase safe consensus. On the other hand, when both sides recognize their place at an expanding feast, the entire art world becomes a regenerative exchange.
Over the next three installments, we will trace how this dynamic plays out across the entire cultural landscape:
Part 2: Stepping inside the studio to look at prolific output, middle-tier gallery bottlenecks, and what happens to the vast reserve of work that never hits a gallery wall.
Part 3: Looking closely at the collector’s world - why buyers value exclusivity, and how direct online relationships are opening new pathways for patronage.
Part 4: Bringing artists, middle-tier dealers, collectors, and independent platforms together to ask what makes the art world a healthy, living ecosystem.
Where do you notice the pull between scarcity and generative thinking in your own creative life or collecting habits? Hit reply or leave a comment—I’d love to hear your perspective.




I never understood the secretiveness of artists not sharing knowledge in order to help out other artists. Some years ago I had an AAA auto guy come over to put a new battery in my car. He was young and we got to talking and he asked if he could show me his portfolio. I was happy to and loved his work. He asked me how to get his foot into the art world and I told him all I knew and gave him all sorts of ideas. I think he contacted me once a year later and he was still doing his art and putting into practice some of the things I mentioned to him. I really wanted to encourage him because I believed in him/in his art. I'd have other artists ask me about the various glues I used for attaching my stuff and I was always happy to share that info. Over the years I have lost contact with many professional artists but there is one I know who gave me some good ideas as to how to go about getting my latest work out there again. I don't see the artists as in competition with each other at all as we all have something to offer someone who is looking for their particular taste in art.
I'm an "Internationally Unknown" artist who made me living by giving away as much information I could stuff into my students, co-creators, and patron's heads (teacher, art teacher, quilt guild founder, librarian). I LOVE to share the knowledge forward, as much as possible because the world is definitely the Ever Expanding Feast. But I didn't like selling my work, my art quilts are slow to produce, and the work on paper is likely too personal. I do enjoy sharing my work, but have avoided the Internet and most of Social Media. And although I have a massive fabric collection, I still accumulate more, and still buy art supplies before the old stuff is used up. So I operate inside The Fixed Pie in my own art creation, but share my knowledge and encourage others in my Social environments (local Plein Air Painting group mainly). I have really enjoyed your series on Joy. Exceptional writing, well done.